Gel Battery Vs Lead Acid Battery: Which is Better?

These two battery types are very unclear to many people. Therefore, we cover everything you need to know about gel batteries vs. lead-acid batteries.

Everyone wants a battery with a long life span. This is the reason why the argument over whether to choose a gel battery or an acid battery is still going strong today. Of these two battery components, which is superior?

Due to their reduced release of hydrogen gas from their vent valves, gel batteries are the safer lead acid batteries. Since there is less ventilation, it is safer to install them there. With flooded lead acid batteries, hydrogen release or gassing is a minor safety concern.

To enable you to make a more informed choice, this article will outline the parts of and differences between gel and acid batteries. We have compared Alkaline Battery and Lead Acid Battery, and AGM Battery Vs. Lead-Acid Battery.

Gel Batteries

Gel cell batteries are strong, valve-regulated Pb batteries that use sulfuric acid to add silica fumes to an electrolyte. The static, gel-like mass produced by this chemical reaction gives rise to the name of these batteries, and their operation differs slightly from that of acid batteries.

It is not necessary to top off distilled water or check the water level in gel batteries because their one-way open valves allow internal gasses to mix back into the water. As a result, gel batteries are less prone to vibration, have higher internal resistance, and need less upkeep.

Additionally, gel batteries are also extremely long-lasting and versatile. Due to their small size and low gas emissions when in use, the batteries can be installed inside your home.

Pros

• Sealed
• Spill-proof
• Maintenance free
• Classified as non-hazardous goods for air, rail & road transportation
• Extremely low self-discharge rate
• No gassing
• Withstand a wide range of temperatures
• Withstand shock & vibration better than any other battery
• No terminal corrosion
• MSDS sheets are not required
• Can be installed near sensitive electronic equipment
• Excellent deep cycle performance

Cons

• More expensive than lead acid
• Sensitive to overcharging (although this is not an issue with a correctly specified SMART charger)

Components of a Gel Battery

Metals and chemicals make up the majority of the composition of gel batteries. Some of the main components include:

• Electrolyte: This is the main source of energy for the gel battery; it primarily consists of colloidally suspended gel sulphuric acid. The analytes the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space between the space
• Separator: This prevents the electrodes from coming into contact with one another, which might cause a short circuit. Only ions can pass through because it is constructed of a foam plastic material.
• Electrodes: These are the electrical conductors that link the batteries to the ignition device.
• Holder: Your batteries are kept in this location. To properly charge the gel batteries, it stores a certain amount of current. In order to avoid sparks and fires, it also controls the battery’s energy flow.

Lead Acid Battery

Rechargeable flooded lead-acid batteries, which were developed in 1860, are the most popular and widely utilized kind of lead-acid battery. Lead and lead oxide plates alternate with liquid electrolytes (sulfuric acid and water) in flooded batteries. These components react to create energy through an electrochemical process.

This battery operates in a straightforward manner. A chemical reaction with sulfuric acid is started by a weak electric current, which releases electrons. Due to the accumulation of positive charges on one side of the battery and negative charges on the other, an electrical field that can power devices is created.

Given that this battery casing is so heavy, it is perfect for gadgets that need a high weight-to-power ratio. Examples include motorcycles, heaters, electric cars, etc. Care must be taken when manufacturing, charging, storing, or transporting these batteries because if the casing is compromised, the chemical liquid may leak out.

Pros

• Relatively inexpensive
• Widely available
• Good size-to-capacity ratio
• Good deep cycle performance

Cons

• Requires regular watering and strict maintenance
• Requires charging in designated and ventilated rooms
• Liable to cause injury and corrosion due to spills and leakage
• Requires the use of personal protective equipment (PPE) when handling
• Vents out substantial quantities of flammable hydrogen gas
• Easily damaged if left to over-charge
• Prone to the high self-discharge rate
• Considered hazardous material when transporting

Components of Acid Batteries

Acid batteries are constructed of metals and particular substances that serve as electrodes, separators, electrolytes, and some of the active parts. The major components of acid batteries are highlighted as follows;

• Container: To prevent electrolyte discharge, the top of the battery’s container is made of ebonite, lead-coated wood, glass, ceramic materials, forged plastic, or hard rubber made of bituminous material.
• Lead Plates: Despite the fact that the plates in a lead acid battery are constructed differently, they are all made of the same grid type, which is constructed of lead and active materials.
• Separators: These are thin sheets made of porous rubber, coated lead plates, and glass fiber. The separators are positioned between the plates to provide active insulation and typically have one side with grooves and another with smooth surfaces.
• Battery edges: The battery’s positive and negative margins have diameters of 17.5 mm and 16 mm, respectively.

Further Reading:

• Can You Mix Lead-acid and Lithium Batteries?
• How Do Lead-acid Batteries Work?
• Can Lead-acid Batteries Explode?
• Are AGM Batteries Better Than Lead-acid?
• How to Fill Lead Acid Battery? Lead Acid Battery Watering Tips

Gel Battery Vs. Acid Battery

Understanding the differences between these battery types is critical if you want to select the best one for your application. The following information will help you make a more informed choice.

Battery Type

Acid Batteries are rechargeable batteries that light the objects they come into contact with using an electrolyte made of sulfuric acid. They are perfect for motorized devices, electrical machines, and car batteries.

Previously, four-wheelers, boats, and other vehicles used these rechargeable batteries. These days, they are mostly employed as backup power sources for telecommunications and industrial machinery like forklifts and satellites.

For devices that need a high weight-to-power ratio, gel batteries are the best option because they have a gel-like consistency for a long-lasting active charge. They come in various shapes and sizes depending on the type of battery you want to buy, giving them more flexibility than gel batteries. 

Battery Lifespan

Due to their high activity levels and low self-discharge rate, lead acid batteries have a shorter lifespan than many other batteries, including gel batteries. They can also be quickly recharged by simply reversing the direction of the current through them.

Because gel battery is more resilient and offers the highest charge per weight of any battery chemistry, gel batteries outlast acid batteries by a significant margin. Read How Long Do Lead-acid Batteries Last?

Self-Discharge Rate

Acid batteries are extremely sensitive to moisture, temperature, and environmental changes. This may result in the acid battery fluid freezing or evaporating, which may lead to dendrite formation, hydrogen gas leakage, electrode corrosion, or both. As a result, users should never attempt to open or de-seal an acid battery.

On the other hand, gel batteries don’t leak hydrogen gas and aren’t temperature-sensitive. However, because of electrolytic reactions and deep discharge, if the gel cracks, it could harm the users and the device.

Operating Temperature

An acid battery typically operates between 1 and 50 degrees Celsius. A temperature of 20 to 25 degrees Celsius (1 degree) above zero is advised for storage. At this temperature, the battery voltage is stable and self-discharge is sufficient to prevent freezing. Since this is the case, it is not suggested to store acid batteries at a lower temperature.

Gel batteries should be stored at a temperature of 10 to 20 degrees Celsius above absolute zero (1 C) for optimum performance even though they typically operate between -20 and +45 degrees Celsius.

Storage Maintenance

To ensure their long-term viability, acid batteries, and gel batteries require different maintenance in their storage facilities. It’s best to keep acid batteries upright and away from thermal heat sources like the sun. Maintain a 1.5 V per cell voltage when storing an acid battery for an extended period of time.

On the other hand, gel batteries should be recharged and stored at or below -20 degrees Celsius when not in use. At this temperature, the battery maintains 95% of its initial charge with low internal resistance. Read More: Lead Acid Battery Care: How to Maintain Lead Acid Battery?

Charging

Though they have a lower retention rate, acid batteries charge more quickly than lead batteries. In comparison to a gel battery, an acid battery typically charges in around 2 hours less time. Additionally, gel batteries only need to be charged every two weeks as opposed to every week for acid batteries, which makes them last longer.

Disposal and Recycling

Although both kinds of batteries can be recycled, the process varies depending on the battery. Due to their electrolytic compositions, gel batteries must be taken to a special battery disposal facility as opposed to acid batteries, which can be recycled normally. This can be a problem if there is nowhere nearby to dispose of the batteries, but you should resist the urge to do so without first properly recycling them.

Read More: Can Lead-acid Batteries Be Recycled?

Safety

Since these batteries have safety concerns, appropriate safety measures must be taken when using them to minimize any risks. Acid batteries are typically dangerous; for instance, if an acid battery leaks, it could harm your skin or even corrode the clothing you’re wearing.

If handled improperly, gel batteries can also degrade. Although they do not leak as easily as their counterparts, they are safer and a better choice if you have young children at home.

Can a Lead Acid Battery Charger Charge a Gel Battery?

Yes, a gel battery can be charged with a lead-acid battery charger. Connect your gel cell battery to the charger and release the clamps holding it to the electrical system of your device to begin charging it. After connecting your gel cell battery, connect the charger in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions (usually 2 amps).

The most popular method of charging them is with an automatic voltage regulator, which modifies voltage according to demand by keeping track of the current drawn from each cell separately. To stop them from overcharging, this kind of charger enables you to set distinct voltages for every stage of charging.

Can I Mix Lead-acid and Gel Batteries?

The answer is no if you want to mix lead-acid and gel batteries. They are incompatible because they have dissimilar chemistries, voltages, and capacities. It’s best to keep them separate on your devices so they can each run smoothly without hindering the performance of the others.

Conclusion: Gel Battery Vs. Acid Battery

In general, gel batteries belong to a development classification of lead-acid batteries, but their performance in cycle life, applicable working environment, and safety are better than ordinary lead-acid batteries with liquid electrolytes.

An alternative to flooded lead acid batteries is gel batteries. They’re suited for a battery backup system or an off-grid home. If you’re considering lead-acid batteries, a gel battery is a better choice if you don’t mind the additional cost. You won’t have to worry about maintenance, which is why.

FAQs